It doesn’t matter, or does it?
I’ve written many years ago a concern regarding initiation, I find myself revisiting the same subject matter fitting individual’s into a set rigid rules irrespective of the individual or their needs; the round peg in a square hole analogy.
What is most saddening is that the latest initiation initiative has for me a shocking element which is impersonal indeed I’m struggling to see how it is compatible with the personal nature Srila Prabhupada dealt with his early disciples; and how as the movement increased how he kept the personal element, simple the temple president recommends (this means that the temple president get’s to know those who attend and are getting serious in the bhakti practice)
Alright I’m a realist and understand that this still works fine in a small center/temple but in much larger center’s/temples this is totally impractical and totally impossible; we can only make personal connections with a limited number.
So we now have a committee system, coupled with the mentor-ship system, I am little unopposed to the latter indeed it’s practice; but committee?
My own personal experience is this, their judgement is based on false not real knowledge, have they done the questions? Lets read them. Have they done Bhakti sastra? Did they complete the course? Have they filled in a sadhna form?
The conclusion is based on these forms, and initiation rewarded accordingly, or in my case constantly rejected. With no knowledge or spoken word to me. How can this be seen as healthy or fair.
The result is simple, the feeling of rejection and that no one is actually interested in speaking or getting to know me or the person up for initiation. I wonder how we can actually speak of developing a personal relationship with Krishna, if we cannot actually develop a personal relationship with devotees. Even worse how can we judge an individual’s fitness based on a set of forms?
Mentor-ship is wonderful, it means getting to really know the individual, over my time attending the same temple it is personal relationship’s that have sustained me, enthused me, guided me and when needed challenged me.
It is these department head’s that I’ve worked closely with who have kept me firmly fixed in devotional service; and unlike the committee members who don’t speak to you personally, it is these great mentor’s that have picked up the pieces.
Mentor is not about making sure form’s are filled in, courses are done and paperwork is filled in, in order to satisfy a committee member. A mentor is those amazing individual’s who take time to understand an individual, engage the individual in seva; and are able to guide, correct and encourage.
So I suggested a simple non-committee system; why not use our department heads?
You simply work alongside them and over time develop a relationship which guides the individual towards first/second initiation. Its these department head’s that have been the greatest influence on my spiritual life, who better to speak on and recommend?
This keeps things very personal, after a period of time then they can speak to the temple/centre president, from their several thing’s can happen-
1) recommendation is given for initiation
2) guidance on further step’s that need to be taken before recommendation
3) meet the individual and after spending some time then make recommendation or give recommendation for initiation
But apparently we need committees and we need to boil the milk as we now have plenty of devotee’s, Hum? If were boiling milk make sure our systems aren’t burning the milk or boiling it so much were spilling it; devotees are rare and we need to encourage not discourage.
So upset and rejected did the committee system make me feel that this was the letter I sent to those department heads who have helped me so nicely, and my guru maharaja;
Dear Guru Maharajah
Dear friends and ever well-wishers
Please Accept My Humble Obeisances
All Glories to Srila Prabhupada
Hare Krishna
This e-mail has proved to be difficult to write as I have difficulty bringing the words needed to express my feelings, but as some of you are aware my visit to Bhaktivadanta Manor this month may prove to be one of my last.
Last month I wrote to one senior devotee and expressed my feelings that although Srila Prabhupada made a home we could all live in as it stands at the moment I cannot see my place in it; this was further highlighted as I spoke to a very dear friend and we discussed why individuals leave ISKCON we ended up discussing my own personal situation, the highlight was the conclusion of faith, if we loose faith then falldown.
As much as I have enjoyed reading Srila Prabhupada’s books and continue to have complete faith in his words, I have the sadness to report that my faith in the institution Srila Prabhuapada set up is lost; my feeling is that the modern ISKCON does no longer want or need individuals like myself.
I remember clearly the challenge my dear guru maharaja HH Devamrita Swami gave me, it made such an impact that over the years I’ve tried my best to fulfil this challenge to simply use my work and contact with those I care for to look after not only the spirit soul but material body.
Over the years I started school visits, and have each year put on a small but growing community Diwali celebration, then explored using my experience in door to door ministry offering a small gita course. Feeling I needed experience the opportunity to give class at the manor was opened and under the guidance of some wonderful devotees have grown in confidence and improved the way class is given.
But for me their was one service that I relished above all, that was serving Sri Sri Radhagakulananda who would have known how amazing the early morning transfers would be; and the bramachari’s were so kind as to re-arrange things so that on each visit I could enter into this nectar of service.
The dearest friend who I have helped during each visit talked about the nectar of putting the deities to rest, the seed was planted and during each visit the desire has grown but in order to do this second initiation is needed; my dear friend and the person I have worked with closely was so happy to recommend me, but the committee rejected
I cannot even mention how much of a personal body blow this was; but my desire to one day help put the deities to rest was just growing.
After many problems in trying to find a mentor that the initiation committee would accept I thought my problems were finally being solved and their was some light at the end of the tunnel; but alas I ended up staring into the well of rejection. We all have strengths and weaknesses mine is paperwork and forms just ask my employer only the essential legally required forms are done, and as for meetings their always behind by a month or so, but they overlook this.
But what is so so hard to accept is the impersonal committee who decide on if some one is worthy are can be given initiation without even spending time with the person, it appears they are more concerned with forms and how nicely the questions are answered than forming a personal relationship with the person.
Even in my time as a Jehovah’s Witness such impersonal systems were not seen, the elders each came to my home we discussed each chapter of the book needed, they had seen and done the house to house ministery with me and had listened to me do public speaking; recommendation was done with knowledge.
However in ISKCON a committee can reject me and they have never come to any programs here in Wales, come to my Diwali celebration, never sat in my class and have never sat eating prasadam with me how can they then say if I’m fit or not? How can it be based on real knowledge of the individual? Do they know the real reason why the person has asked or requested or made the steps the motivation? Or the many hours each month using social media to encourage and answer questions from new devotees?
My desire was simply to allow me to do more service, but a No by individual’s who don’t know me is a pill too hard to swallow; but more significantly is this it has broken my heart I was certain Sri Krishna would reciprocate nicely but this sadly wasn’t to be. And so it came to the point were the pain became too much for me to beer and my mind became tormented so much how could I continue to do the morning transfers? This torment meant that my dealings with others became strained for one just feels rejection.
We all need to feel needed, that we have a place; that we are an individual and are seen as such; what attracted me first to the devotees was their real interest in the person, this appears to have been lost in standardisation and committees. But I need that real individual touch.
So my heart is torn, demoralised, heartbroken how can I go smile and do service knowing that my deep down desire will never be fulfilled?
One of my dearest friend and ever well-wisher has suggested I help his disciples in opening a small shop come centre in Bristol; I have approached the devotee who is in charge and awaiting to hear back; their fear is my heart is too broken to continue having association as I can only see things now in an impersonalist manor this is my feeing about current management structures.
I’ve also tried to be mindful of those who somehow see me as a senior devotee, and who have also approached and have asked me for help via social media so as not to discourage them I have simply informed them that my service is in transition and changing
The main point is I no longer feel a part or have a place in this new modern standardised ISKCON, I long for those early days when I was simply accepted for being me.
I pray that one day my outlook may become more positive and that again I may feel a wanted and needed member.
Yours Humbly
Dhirabhakta Dasa
Of note I had replies back from those great saintly people who had actually got to know me; even my guru maharaja replied more rapidly than any other time. Those department heads I’ve worked alongside took time to talk and encourage; and I even found that those who meant the most to me had enough belief in me to ask me to continue giving Srimad Bhagavatam Class.
Although my own self belief and ability to focus was shattered.
I however had one great bit of advice; “IT DOESN’T MATTER”
So what a committee rejected you, it doesn’t matter
They simply reminded me of the two greatest things.
Devotional service and our relationship with those who have our spiritual interests at heart.
And so I have come out of the Mentor-ship system, and will not ask or make any effort to seek second initiation; non of these things matter
What matters is that I simply focus on my own personal relationship with those I do service for, those who seek and ask my guidance, and to improve and increase my relationship with devotees who want to be for real with me.
For this personal relationship is for me what matters, so why be disturbed by nonsense impersonal individual and systems; for it truly “DOESN’T MATTER”
And it again reminded me that my greatest battle, and greatest hindrance in spiritual life is not, individual’s, committees but as always the greatest field of nonsense
MY MIND
And getting that right is were it matters.
And my relationship with some amazing devotees and department heads is all the mentor-ship I need for they being in full knowledge of me give the soundest and greatest advice.
And my own Guru Maharaja’s advice; what ever happens don’t give up association of devotees
And it is those great devotees that truly care who have picked me up and shown me what really matters, and that a view taken from a few TRULY DOESN’T MATTER.
Hare Krishna